Home
Click here to: Read past issues of Being Jewish Magazine>> Find out how to submit your writing, poetry or art and GET PUBLISHED in a future issue>> Get subscription information
Click here to browse all past emails of the week and to submit your own email (all published emails are anonymous -- of course!)
Click here to: GET A FREE DOWNLOAD of the 1st 2 chapters of Gil's book>> Read book reviews >>Purchase the book...at a special discount!
Looking for a recipe?  Want to submit a recipe?  Together with you, we can REALLY COOK! Click here.
Want to see your work in print?  Most of the content in Being Jewish Magazine (Circulation average:  100,000 + households!)  comes from our readers!  We welcome submissions from writers and artist -- from professional to amateur!  Click here to find out how to send us your work.
To help you search the vast Internet, click here for a few of our favorite Jewish links by topic.
Who is this guy anyway?  Click here to find out more!
Click here to email us.  We are anxious to hear your comments:  >>How can we serve you better? >>What information about Judaism interests you? >>Suggestions to improve this website of the magazine>>Any other comment under the sun!

 

Google



Search WWW 
Search beingjewish.org


The ESP of the
Jewish Way of Life
 
Roll your mouse over each circle to find the questions.
Ethics Spirituality Peoplehood
Click on circles for more about Jewish ESP!


Ask Gil
Dear Readers: I LOVE READING YOUR EMAIL!!!! SO, if you'd like to say something about this website, the Email of the Week column or have a different Jewish issue/question on your mind please send it in. I am always looking for emails for future columns and a book I am writing (you will remain anonymous, of course). So, please email me at GilMann@BeingJewish.org just click on the blue letters. I look forward to your emails! 

Thanks,
Gil


 

Dear Readers,

These columns began on my area of America Online, called:  Judaism Today:  Where Do I Fit?   People anonymously sent me E-Mail, and I began to choose one for a public response in my Jewish E-Mail of the Week column. The column has become quite popular and is now syndicated internationally in many Jewish papers and websites.  I hope you find they help you as you think about the Ethics, Spirituality and Peoplehood components of the Jewish way of Life.  I welcome your comments... see the end of the column.

Gil

PS  Teachers and others, feel free to copy my columns and forward them or use them as you see fit.  Please see the friendly copyright notice at the end.

WHERE IS JUDAISM WHEN I AM ALONE?

 

Dear Gil:

There is a place for Judaism when I'm with my family and with others in the Jewish community. But where is Judaism when I'm alone in the house? When I'm walking the dog by the lake? When I am in pain? I know where Judaism is in the community - it is in my wallet. Where is it when I need G-d?

K

 

Dear K:

Many have asked me questions like yours about finding God when you are alone.

You may be surprised to know that Judaism definitely maintains that you can find God by yourself...and not just during services. Many Jews don't realize this and think Judaism does not care about individuals finding God. I am not sure where the misconception came from. Perhaps it is hearing Christians regularly speak of a having "personal relationship" with God--something we Jews don't speak about often.

Perhaps another reason Jews have a misconception about individual relationships with God is the traditional emphasis on praying in a Minyon--that is 10 or more individuals. Judaism as a religion is not unique in placing an emphasis on praying as a community (one reason there are such institutions such as churches, mosques, monasteries, etc.) There are numerous reasons for and advantages to gathering with others for communal prayer that I won't get into here. What is important to realize is that finding God by yourself is "kosher" so to speak.

Even though Jews do not usually use the term "personal relationship" to describe God, we could since Judaism includes the concept. You need look no further than the silent meditation that is found in every Jewish service called the Amidah--the central part of the Jewish service. During the Amidah each of us has the opportunity for our own private thoughts, prayers, contemplations and meditations. For this reason, the Amidah is probably my favorite part of a Jewish service.

But outside of the service, we are regularly told to search for God and be mindful of God...even when we are walking by the lake with the dog. In fact, when you are outside appreciating nature, I can think of no easier time to make a connection with God. (Often rather than use the word God, people have said to me that in nature they are aware of or in awe of a life force or a creator, bigger than us.)

Whatever term you use, here is a prayer or meditation you might find meaningful: "May it by my custom to go outdoors each day amongst the trees and grasses, among all living things and there may I be alone and enter into prayer to talk with the one that I belong to. Sounds Native American doesn't it--or maybe even Eastern? It is Eastern....Eastern European Judaism that is! This quote is from the famous Rabbi Nachman of Bratzlov.

But before you get too carried away with your individual searching, here is a thought from a modern rabbi, Yitz Greenberg. He says that Judaism "views self as the basis of human dignity...yet incomplete by itself." Continuing his thinking, he quotes the famous words of our ancient Rabbi Hillel "If I am not for myself, who will be for me? But, when I am for myself [alone], what am I?"

In Hillel's words are a response to your comment about community. I think of Jewish community as extended family. You and I are part of the Jewish community and the Jewish community is part of us (even when you may feel resentment about a member of the community asking for your money.) In reality, the Jewish community is not about money--it is about the collective responsibility we each have for each other and our collective strength as individuals together.

In the case of the community, I'll add that you should not judge the whole community based on one or several individuals. I too am a part of your community and I have no interest in your wallet. My interest is try and help you and as many others as I can to appreciate how Judaism can make themselves and the world better. Limited as I am by space, still I hope I have succeeded a bit in this effort and in giving you a hand.

Thanks for writing,

Gil



A FRIENDLY COPYRIGHT NOTICE
© Copyright Gil Mann

These columns can be found at www.beingjewish.org.  Not only do I give you permissions to copy these Jewish Email columns...I HOPE YOU WILL and that you share them with others!  All I ask is that you never charge anyone for them and that you also include this little copyright notice.  Thank You!
Ask Gil
Dear Readers: I LOVE READING YOUR EMAIL!!!! SO, if you'd like to say something about this website, the Email of the Week column or have a different Jewish issue/question on your mind please send it in. I am always looking for emails for future columns and a book I am writing (you will remain anonymous, of course). So, please email me at GilMann@BeingJewish.org just click on the blue letters. I look forward to your emails! 

Thanks,
Gil

Home | Index of Past Columns | Previous Article | Next Article